Silly-Costume Nativity Play for Teens
- Kelly Kirstein
- 8 hours ago
- 3 min read
If you’re looking for a fun, meaningful, and totally unforgettable way to teach the Christmas story, let me introduce you to one of my favorite ideas of all time:
the Silly-Costume Nativity Play.
It’s engaging, biblical, hilarious, and deeply powerful for students who may have never heard the real Christmas story before.
This is an easy, ready-to-use program you can run with middle school or high school students. It works perfectly for youth group nights, small groups, Christmas parties, or a December outreach event.
Below is your full guide, including setup instructions, supplies, roles, and tips for making it a moment your teens will remember.
Why This Nativity Works So Well for Youth Ministry
Most teens know “pieces” of the Nativity, but many have never heard the full story straight from Scripture. This activity lets them experience the story with movement, costumes, small parts, and laughter—while still hearing the real passages straight from Luke and Matthew.
Youth leaders love this because:
• Works for Groups of All Sizes (up to 30 teens)
• It requires minimal prep
• Students stay engaged
• It naturally opens doors for gospel conversation
• It’s inclusive—every student gets a part
• It’s fun enough to share on social media
And kids LOVE it because they get to dress up in the most ridiculous costumes they can find.
How to Lead a Silly-Costume Nativity Play With Your Students
1. Gather the Supplies
Make this as easy or as silly as you want. Encourage them to raid their closets, use props from the youth room, or bring random costume items.
Here are ideas you can use or provide:
•Used Plastic Table Cloths
• Old T-shirts
•Animal hats
• Funny hats or headbands
• Scarves, blankets, robes, pajamas
• Tinsel halos
• A large star cutout•
Pool noodle staffs•
Stuffed animals for the stable
You do not need perfect costumes. The sillier the better!
2. Print the Script and Assign Roles
I recommend using a script that includes the actual Bible verses from Luke 1:26–40 and Matthew 1:18–2:23 so that students hear the story as God wrote it.
Key roles for youth ministry:
• 3 Narrators
• Mary
• Joseph
• Angel Gabriel
• Innkeeper
• Donkey
• Shepherds
• Wise Men
• Heavenly Hosts
• Stable animals
• Star of Bethlehem
Optional: Royal Messenger
Try to spread out parts so every student has a moment to shine.
Click Here for Your Free Printable
3. Set Up a Simple Stage Area
This can be done in any room. You just need an open space.
Students move from one side to the other as the narrators read.
No microphones or lighting needed—just space.
4. Invite Students to Have Fun With It
This is where the magic happens.
Tell the kids: “Make your character your own. Be dramatic. Be goofy. Have fun—just keep the story respectful.”
You’ll see them come alive.
• Donkeys braying
• Shepherds overacting
• Wise Men taking their roles way too seriously
• Angels doing big dramatic entrances
Enjoy it. They will remember it forever.
5. Let Narrators Read the Actual Bible Story
Your three narrators rotate reading through the Scripture passages that tell the Nativity story. This anchors the fun in truth.
While Scripture is read, students act out the scenes.
This creates a powerful teaching moment because teens:
• Hear the Word
• See the story acted out
• Understand it in a fresh way
6. Close With a Short Devotional or Discussion
After the final scene, gather everyone around and ask a few simple questions:
• What surprised you about the real Christmas story?
• What part stood out to you the most?
• Why do you think God chose such humble people and places for Jesus’ birth?
• What does this story show us about who Jesus is?
Students often open up in ways they wouldn’t during a normal sermon-style lesson.
Why Your Group Will Love This
When students play the Nativity instead of only hearing it, something special happens:
They remember it. They understand it. They connect with it emotionally. And they leave knowing Jesus came for them—and still meets them where they are today.
Another Fun Christmas Idea:
Comments