You Are Their Mentor, Not Their Counselor: Healthy Boundaries for Bible Study Leaders
When you sit around a table with teen girls long enough, eventually someone is going to tell you something hard.
Maybe she is struggling with anxiety. Maybe she tells you she feels depressed. Maybe things at home aren't good. Maybe she has been carrying something painful for years and finally feels safe enough to say it out loud.
These are sacred moments in mentoring.
They can also feel intimidating.
You may find yourself thinking, What am I supposed to say? What if I say the wrong thing? Am I supposed to know how to help her with this?
Here's something every mentor needs permission to understand:
You don't have to know how to fix everything a teen girl brings to the table.
In fact, sometimes the most responsible and loving thing you can do is recognize when what she needs goes beyond what you are equipped to provide.
First, Know Your Role
Having healthy boundaries as a Bible study leader, means you understand you play a part in her life, and it is not her counselor.
Merriam-Webster defines a mentor as “a person who gives help and advice to a less experienced and often younger person especially in a professional or academic context.”
That is very different from the role of a mental health counselor.
A mental health counselor is a trained professional who helps people work through emotional, behavioral, psychological, and mental health challenges. Depending on the setting and jurisdiction, professional counselors typically have specialized education, supervised clinical experience, and licensure or other professional credentials.
As Bible study leaders and mentors, most of us don't have that training.
And that's okay.
God hasn't asked us to become someone's therapist simply because He has placed a hurting girl at our Bible study table.
He has called us to love her, listen to her, point her toward truth, pray with her, encourage her and, when necessary, help her get to the adults and professionals who are equipped to give her the help she needs.
Think about Paul's description of the body of Christ:
We don't all have the same role.
A mentor doesn't become less valuable because a girl also needs a counselor. A counselor doesn't replace the spiritual influence of a loving mentor.
They can serve very different purposes in the life of the same girl.
Stay in Your Lane, But Don't Step Out of Her Life
Healthy boundaries don't mean becoming distant.
They mean understanding what belongs to you and what doesn't.
As a mentor, DO:
Listen without immediately trying to fix it. Sometimes a girl needs a trustworthy adult who will calmly listen to what she is experiencing.
James 1:19 reminds us to be “quick to listen, slow to speak.” That's wonderful mentoring advice.
Help her identify trustworthy adults. Teach girls that asking for help is a sign of wisdom. Depending on the situation, that might mean talking with a parent, guardian, school counselor, pastor, doctor or licensed mental health professional.
Encourage communication with parents whenever it is safe and appropriate. Rather than becoming the person standing between a teen and her parents, look for opportunities to strengthen healthy communication.
You might say, “Have you told your mom or dad how you've been feeling?” or “Would it help if we thought about how you could start that conversation?”
Pray with her and point her toward biblical truth.
You absolutely can remind her who God is, what Scripture says and that Jesus is present with her in difficult places.
Know when something is beyond your ability to help. Recognizing your limitations isn't failure. It is wisdom.
Proverbs 11:14 tells us,
As a mentor, DON'T:
Don't diagnose a teen with depression, anxiety, trauma, ADHD or another mental health condition.
Don't tell her to stop taking medication or suggest that she doesn't need professional treatment.
Don't try to provide therapy you aren't trained to provide.
Don't promise absolute confidentiality. There are situations involving safety, abuse, self-harm or suicidal thoughts when another responsible adult must become involved.
Don't assume every emotional or mental health struggle is primarily a spiritual problem.
Don't make yourself the only person she believes she can talk to.
And don't carry responsibility God never gave you.
Your job isn't to become everything she needs. Your job is to faithfully help her take the next right step.
When Hard Family Situations Come to the Bible Study Table
Bible studies should be places where girls feel safe enough to be honest.
But safe enough to share doesn't mean every detail needs to be shared with everyone in the room.
Teen girls can be living through incredibly difficult situations at home. Sometimes those experiences will surface during Bible study.
When that happens, we have several people to protect.
We want to protect the girl who is sharing.
We want to protect the dignity and privacy of her family.
And we want to protect the other girls sitting around the table from being exposed to traumatic details they may not be emotionally ready to process.
That doesn't mean silencing a girl.
It means gently helping her recognize which conversations belong in the group and which conversations need to continue privately with an appropriate adult.
You might say:
"I'm really glad you told us you're going through something difficult at home. You don't need to tell us all the details here, but I'd like to talk with you after Bible study so we can figure out who can help you."
Notice what that does.
You aren't telling her that what happened doesn't matter.
You aren't suggesting that she isn't telling the truth.
You aren't defending harmful behavior.
You are simply protecting everyone's dignity while making sure the situation receives appropriate attention.
And, of course, if a girl discloses suspected abuse, neglect, exploitation or another situation covered by your state's reporting laws, follow your organization's child-protection policies and applicable reporting requirements. Privacy should never be used as a reason to ignore a child's safety.
Mental Health Struggles Are Not Evidence of Weak Faith
This is something our girls desperately need to hear.
A teen can genuinely love Jesus and still struggle with anxiety.
She can have strong faith and experience depression.
She can worship, pray, read her Bible and still need counseling.
One does not cancel out the other.
Sometimes girls are afraid to tell Christian adults what they are experiencing because they think we're going to question their faith.
"You just need to trust God more."
"You need to pray harder."
"If you really believed what Scripture says, you wouldn't feel this way."
Those statements can place tremendous spiritual shame on a girl who is already struggling.
Instead, help her understand that what she is feeling tells us that something is happening inside of her that deserves attention.
Psalm 139:23–24 gives us a beautiful picture of bringing our internal world before God:
God isn't afraid of what is happening inside of us.
We shouldn't teach girls to be afraid of it either.
Mental Health Struggles Don't Mean Someone Is “Crazy”
Having a mental health condition does not mean someone is crazy.
And we should be extremely careful about automatically attributing depression, anxiety or another mental health condition to demonic activity.
Scripture certainly teaches us that spiritual warfare is real. But Scripture does not give us permission to label every psychological or medical problem as demonic.
We live in a broken world.
Our bodies are affected by that brokenness, and the brain is part of the body. Mental and emotional struggles can have biological, psychological, relational, environmental and spiritual dimensions.
Sometimes someone needs prayer.
Sometimes she needs counseling.
Sometimes she needs medical care.
Sometimes she needs changes in her environment.
And sometimes she needs several of those things at once.
Seeking appropriate help doesn't compete with trusting Jesus.
It can be part of wisely caring for the life He has given us.
Following Jesus Doesn't Mean Life Suddenly Becomes Easy
We also need to be careful about the message that accepting Jesus will make all of someone's problems disappear.
Jesus never promised that.
Actually, He told His disciples the opposite.
Jesus doesn't promise us a trouble-free life.
He promises that trouble doesn't get the final word. That distinction matters.
When a girl chooses to follow Jesus, she doesn't suddenly become immune to grief, trauma, family problems, anxiety, depression, disappointment or loss.
What changes is that she no longer walks through those things without Him.
Jesus can lead her toward healing. He can renew her mind. He can reveal truth. He can bring trustworthy people into her life. And sometimes one of those people may be a professional counselor whom God has gifted, trained and equipped to help her work through something she cannot navigate alone.
There is no shame in receiving that help.
When Self-Harm or Suicide Comes Up
There are some disclosures that should immediately change how we respond.
If a teen tells you she is hurting herself, thinking about suicide, has a suicide plan, has attempted suicide or believes she may hurt herself, do not treat that as an ordinary Bible study conversation.
Take it seriously.
Don't promise to keep it secret.
Don't leave her alone to manage it.
Don't assume prayer by itself has resolved the immediate safety concern.
Bring in a parent or guardian and appropriate professional or emergency support according to the situation and your organization's safety procedures. If there is reason to believe involving a particular parent or guardian could place the teen in danger, follow your organization's child-safety procedures and applicable reporting requirements rather than attempting to manage the situation yourself.
You can tell her:
"I care about you too much to keep something this serious to myself. We're going to get you some help, and I'm going to stay with you while we figure out the next step."
That isn't betraying her trust.
That's protecting her.
Teach Girls How to Ask for Help
One of the greatest skills we can give teenagers is knowing what kind of help they need and which adult to ask for it.
If a girl tells you she has been feeling anxious, depressed, overwhelmed or emotionally unwell, encourage her to talk with her parents or guardians and, when appropriate, a school counselor, health-care provider or mental health professional.
Don't simply tell her, “You need counseling.”
Help her learn how to ask for help.
She might begin with:
"I've been struggling lately, and I don't think I know how to handle it by myself. Can you help me find someone I can talk to?"
That is a life skill she can carry into adulthood.
Galatians 6:2 tells us:
Bearing someone's burden doesn't always mean carrying it ourselves.
Sometimes it means helping her find someone better equipped to carry part of it with her.
The Truth Is, We All Have Mental and Emotional Health
We often talk about “mental health” as though it is something only struggling people have.
But everyone has mental and emotional health.
Just like we learn to care for our physical bodies, we need to learn to recognize what is happening in our thoughts, emotions and internal world.
For followers of Jesus, that process has an incredible starting point.
We can bring what is happening inside of us to the One who created us.
David writes:
God knows the parts of us we understand.
He knows the parts we don't understand.
He knows the pain we haven't found words for yet.
He knows what needs healing, what needs changing and where we need help.
That is one reason spending time with Jesus matters so deeply.
We aren't pretending difficult things don't exist.
We are learning to bring our whole selves before God and allow Him to lead us toward truth, wisdom, healing and the help we need.
Healthy Boundaries for Bible Study Leaders Means... You Don't Have to Fix Her
When a girl trusts you enough to tell you something painful, you may feel enormous pressure to make it better.
Release yourself from that pressure.
You aren't her Savior.
Jesus already has that position.
You aren't her counselor.
Someone else may be called and professionally equipped for that role.
You are her mentor.
You can listen.
You can notice.
You can pray.
You can speak truth.
You can remind her that asking for help isn't shameful.
You can recognize when something is beyond your role.
You can help her find the right adult.
And you can continue walking beside her while she gets the help she needs.
That may be one of the most important things a faithful mentor ever does.
Source
“Mentor.” Merriam-Webster.com Dictionary, Merriam-Webster, accessed September 3, 2026. Merriam-Webster defines mentor as “a person who gives help and advice to a less experienced and often younger person especially in a professional or academic context.”
Comments